Nosey Neighbor (Hers) Ch. 12

The following is a work of fiction. All characters participating in sexual activities are over 18. Any resemblance to real life persons is merely coincidental.

This story is part of a series and it is advised to read the story from the beginning as each chapter continues directly from the last. This story is split between the different perspectives of his and hers. To get the full story it is suggested to read both sides.

The Nosey Neighbor - Her Story

By: VanillaUnicorn

All of the residents of the neighborhood started to gather around hoping they could figure out what was going on. It wasn't every day that so many emergency vehicles were there. Outside of the ambulance that had come to haul the broken Kevin away after Emily broke his nuts, there hadn't been anything of that nature there other than a couple of fires a few years prior. It didn't take long for the gossip to start and wild stories to start circulating about what kind of things the Mathews family were into.

The police detectives were still picking up evidence from inside the house and the two women who had been sexually assaulted were driven away to the nearby hospital for some tests. Bob only had minor injuries and he stayed behind to answer whatever questions they had for him. He had already called Kevin and filled him in on what was going on. Instead of heading back to the chaos of his home, the young Mathews boy went straight to the hospital instead so that his mother had someone there with her.

Given what had happened she didn't really want to see her son though. She tried to get him to leave but he made it clear he wasn't going anywhere. Another of the city's police detectives were there collecting her side of the story and had just finished up when Kevin got there.

The evidence was clear that she had been raped. While she would never admit it to anyone who asked her, the sex had been some of the best that Evelyn had ever experienced. She knew she had to deny to the police that she welcomed it in any way but deep down after the shock of it happening had worn away she was having the time of her life. Her husband Bob, while a good man, had never pleased her the way those two strangers had. When the nurse came in to administer the pill to block her from becoming pregnant, she almost regretted taking it. She knew she couldn't have either of the men's children without it being obvious since the baby would likely come out darker skinned but the fantasy of that actually happening made her smile some internally.

As Kevin sat outside his mother's room waiting for the doctor to finish up with her, one of the nurses he had as his own when he'd been there came and joined him. She was curious about what had happened and thought he might be able to give her answers. Kevin didn't have any more idea what had happened than the nurse did.

Joanne had made the short trip down to the police station to give her take on what had happened. She left out the part that she knew who the two men were or that her own children were the ones who had initiated the whole thing. She was still furious at all three of them but she would deal with them when she got back home and out of the eyes of the police.

Once the detectives took her statement and asked a few questions they had her point out the two men from a line-up just to verify parts of her story and be sure they had the right people in custody. She easily pointed out both Brian and Nate. The detective thanked her for the help and told her that if they had any follow up questions they would be in contact with her.

Finished at the police station, Joanne drove over to the hospital that Jenna had been sent to. Thankfully Jenna had been placed on a different floor than the one where Evelyn Mathews had been sent because she wasn't ready to face the woman quite yet. It took a bit of slick negotiating to get inside since she wasn't family but Mrs. Schneider was able to get in to see her favorite waitress.

She didn't really show any physical signs of anything having happened to her but Joanne could tell that the young woman wasn't alright based off the way she was staring off into space. Just like the tests from Mrs. Mathews had come back, it was clear that the young woman showed signs of forcible sex. Also just like they had done with Evelyn they gave her a pill to prevent any unwanted pregnancies.

"Mrs. Schneider what are you doing here?" Jenna asked from her hospital bed.

"I'm sorry all of this happened to you. This is all my fault." Joanne said with tears flowing down her face.

"How would it be your fault? You weren't the one who raped me. Honestly it happened so quickly that I still don't even know what went on. I mean I remember dropping your car off at your house and walking up to the door to give back the keys but after that I don't remember anything until I woke up here." Jenna confessed.

"That actually wasn't my house. It's a long story but you were parked at my neighbor's house. You were at the wrong place at the wrong time."

"But the number on the house matched the address that was on your insurance card in the glove box. I even double checked it when I pulled up." Jenna said confused by what she was being told.

"Like I said it's a long story and not one I want to bring up here." Joanne said motioning towards the police officer who was still guarding the doorway to the hospital room.

"Believe me you'll know exactly what happened when the time comes but for now I just want you to focus on getting better." Joanne continued to say cutting off any further questions the confused Jenna had at that moment.

Neither woman got a chance to say anything beyond what they had since the doctor came in to check on Jenna and kicked Mrs. Schneider out of the room. When Joanne went back inside after the doctor left she found that Jenna had gone to sleep. Not wanting to wake her she quietly closed the door to the hospital room and sat down on a bench just down the hallway. Her mind was racing as she was trying to understand just how much trouble her kids had caused.

Back at the house things were wrapping up with the investigation. Most of the police cars had already left and the ones that remained were going over a few last things with Bob. Neither of the Schneider girls knew exactly what had gone on in the house after they had both snuck out. Luke looked like he knew more than his sisters did but he didn't want to say because then he would have to confess to the fact that their mother had walked in on him recording the whole incident.

With it clear that both men had been arrested, Candace suggested that Luke come with her so she could remove any of the two men's stuff from her house and even change the door locks just in case either of them had a key and were granted bail. They both piled into Candace's car and pulled away behind one of the police cruisers that had just finished up with Bob and was on its way back to the station.

The drive to her place was quick but she was nervous about what she might find when she got there. As she pulled into the trailer court, one of the older men that took on the role of caretaker for the place waved her car over.

"Ms. Schneider, I haven't seen you or your kids around for a bit. Some of your neighbors have been lodging some complaints about loud noises at late hours of the night coming from your home. I just want to warn you that if that doesn't change that you might be facing some fines and litigation from the lawyers that manage our fine lot. Oh... before I forget your lawn is also out of control and needs to be cut immediately." The old man told her through the open window of her car.

"The noise won't be a problem anymore Mr. Jones and I'll get right on making sure the grass gets cut." Candace told the man as she started to roll her window back up and then pull away.

The man was right. When she pulled into her driveway the grass was about knee high and was in desperate need of being cut. She had been planning on taking care of it before Brian and his friend showed up but then once they were there she since simply never got the chance. After that she was at her mother's place and hadn't even thought about it.

"Do you think you can do me a favor? Could you cut the grass while I go in and take care of whatever is inside? I promise it shouldn't take very long and the mower should already be good to go. When you're done I should have everything taken care of with those two creep's things and then we can head to the hardware store so I can pick up some new locks." Candace begged her brother.

"You owe me for this you know that right?" Luke said as he stepped out of the car and looked over what she was asking him to do.

"Oh I know. If nothing else when we finish up I'll buy you some cold beer and after mom brings you back to school I'll drop some more off with you there." Candace said with a smile hoping that would be enough to satisfy him.

As Luke wandered over to the rusty old lawnmower, Candace went up and unlocked her door. Poking her head inside, she saw that her place had been trashed. The two men who had been squatting there were absolute pigs and left trash everywhere. Dirty clothes were just carelessly tossed everywhere and dishes sat out with spoiled food rotting in them. She was furious but it just motivated her even more to get everything done. She went to the cupboard under her sink and pulled out the box of trash bags. Steadily she walked around tossing anything that didn't belong to her or her kids into the bags. The dishes were picked up and dropped into the waiting sink. It took a bit of time but eventually she had her living room looking somewhat decent again.

Luke wasn't fairing so well outside. The lawnmower had been so poorly maintained that he would make it a couple feet in the grass before it would die. He'd fire it back up or at least try to and then go again. Some guy was walking by and suggested some things in how to fix it but Luke just ignored him.

Back inside Candace piled the bags she had already filled by the door and worked her way to her bedroom. It was even worse than the living room had been. To make things even more disgusting, she found spent condoms just dropped randomly on the floor. It took about an hour but she collected up everything in the room she wanted gone and put it all together in the bags including those used condoms. All said and done she had filled a dozen large trash bags that needed to be tossed out.

She started hauling them out bag by bag and threw them in the large dumpster the people of her trailer court shared. It was a good thing it had been mostly empty because she filled it half full just with everything she heaved into it from her place.

Right around the time she finished with the last bag, Luke had managed to cut the tiny bit of remaining wildly grown grass in the front of the double-wide trailer home. He had worked up a sweat doing the physical labor and Candace offered to let him use her shower to get cleaned up. Since he was occupied, she went around and took closer note of everything. Her fridge was empty of any food as were her cabinets. Her mail had been stacked up on the table with some of it opened by the two men. Her answering machine had been wiped clean of any messages but the caller id showed that plenty of people had called while she was away.

Luke had just finished up drying himself off and getting dressed when someone knocked on Candace's door. She sprang up to see who it might be and got nervous when she saw that it was a plain clothed police officer that was standing there. She could tell he was a cop based off his badge hanging off his belt and the unmistakable police cruiser he had parked in her driveway. It may not have had lights on the roof or the paint job that would normally be associated with a police vehicle but she had seen plenty of police television shows to know what an unmarked car looked like.

"Evening ma'am, I'm detective Gutiérrez. Are you Ms. Candace Schneider?" The man asked after double checking the name on the papers in his hand.

"I am. How can I help you officer?" Candace replied back.

"I have some questions I'd like to ask you about a case I've been assigned. If that it's alright may I step inside so we can speak in private?" The man asked.

"Sure no problem, please come in." Candace said gesturing for the man to move passed her.

The officer started to look around her place but didn't say a word. He could tell that it had just recently been cleaned but that didn't really prove the story he'd been told. Moving over to the couch he motioned for Candace to join him in a nearby chair.

"Please this shouldn't take long ma'am. I just have a few questions like I've said. First off do you live alone and how long have you lived here?" The man asked.

"Yes... Well no, I have two kids that live here too. I want to say that we've been here somewhere around two years."

"Ok then who would the gentleman be that is currently in the kitchen?" He asked pointing his finger in the direction of Luke.

"Oh that's just my brother. He came by to give me a hand with my yard work." Candace answered after she turned her head to see Luke rummaging through her fridge.

"Ah, well earlier today there was an incident that happened in the neighborhood of your family's home. When we questioned the persons involved, your name and your sister's name were mentioned to us. Do you know these two men at all?" The officer asked showing her the mugshots of Brian and Nate.

"No. No, I can't say I've seen either of those two before." Candace said flat out lying to the cop.

The officer started to write some notes on the paperwork he had carried in with him and Candace got a little more nervous. Luke had been listening to the whole exchange and he shot his sister a quick glance that told her to keep going but don't say anything that might get either of them in trouble.

"Would it be alright if I looked around your house here?" He asked.

"No that's fine." Candace answered knowing that she had already gotten rid of every trace of the two men being there.

The officer stood up and started to walk around the house stopping here and there to get a closer look at everything. He looked in her kids' rooms briefly and then came back out. He checked in the bathroom and found nothing again. Each time he left one of the rooms he would jot down more on his little notepad. He went into Candace's bedroom last and took note of some unusual stains on the floor near the bed. Nothing seemed to corroborate the two men's story though. They had told the detectives that they had been called over to the house they were found in by the two Schneider sisters and lured up to the bedrooms with the promise of sex. They claimed self-defense for their attack on Bob Mathews, saying that he had swung at them first and didn't identify himself as the home owner at all. When it came to the sexual assault charges they were each facing, they each said that what had happened had been consensual by everyone involved.

After interviewing both of the attacked women and taking Mrs. Schneiders statement to what she saw, none of the facts seemed to match up to the story the men were telling them. The preliminary reports showed that the assaulted women showed signs of forcible sexual contact but until they got the DNA testing back they couldn't definitively prove that it was either Brian or Nate or even someone else who had done it. No one else in the neighborhood had reported seeing anything out of the ordinary and Brian's car was also parked in the Mathews driveway.

Not finding anything to back up their claims in her home, the officer asked her a few more questions and then left. Luke had been sweating bullets but once the cop left he assumed they were in the clear. The plan had gone slightly off the rails since they had never planned for anyone to get hurt but in a way it also worked out better for them because it meant the two men were likely going to be jailed for even longer than the plan had been for.

"What the fuck Luke? They know we had something to do with it I just know it." A panicked Candace said as she started to pace around in her living room.

"No they don't. If they did we would be in cuffs already. As long as everyone keeps their mouths shut there isn't anything to prove we had anything to do with it. Well... Well there is the tape I made but mom took it and I doubt she would ever give it to them." Luke said trying to reassure himself more than he was his sister.

"What tape?"

"Umm I kinda recorded part of what happened. Don't worry you aren't on there, well outside of it showing you both walking over but Em is definitely on it. I don't know where you were at inside so I couldn't pan it over to show you any. It was focused on Kevin's room since his was directly across from the guest bedroom in our house." He confessed.

"And exactly why were you recording in the first place?"

"I was hoping to use it to embarrass Kevin. You know show him what happened in his room just to piss him off." Luke said with a smile.

"So it had nothing to do with you wanting to see our sister naked again? I know all about what you guys did while I was gone with the kids. Emily told me everything. She even made sure to bring up the fact that you tried to rape her. What the hell is wrong with you?" Candace practically screamed.

"No I was going to edit her out before I gave the video to Kevin. It doesn't matter now though, mom has the tape and there is no way she would give it back to me. And I didn't try to rape her. She was just as much into it as I was. Besides it's a good thing we didn't screw because then I would've never found those two guys following me." Luke said trying to justify himself.

"You're gross you know that? If you ever try anything like that with me I'll cut both of your balls and your little dick off and make you eat them. Then I'll tell mom all about it and then she can kick your ass too." Candace said before leaving her brother standing shocked in the living room while she went to grab a bottled water from the kitchen.

After downing the water in one go, Candace didn't say a word as she stepped outside to check on the work her brother had done in her yard. She didn't have to go far to see that he wasn't done yet. He had only cut the patch in front of the trailer home that went to the road and hadn't even touched the part that was on the side or the back. She let out a frustrated sigh and went back inside.

"What the hell Luke you said you were done. You only did a third of it." She yelled at him.

"You never said anything about any of that. You only told me to cut your jungle grass out front. Besides, the mower is out of gas." Luke complained.

"We can get more when we stop to get a new lock set from the store. Get your shoes on lets go." She barked at him.

As the two siblings piled into Candace's car and drove off things were picking up at the hospital. Since he was done with the police questioning at his house Bob had gone to see about his wife in the hospital. When the doctors explained to him what had happened to his wife, Bob went berserk. He had been unconscious the whole time that both men did what they did with the women and had no clue what they faced. When the police and ambulance showed up he was pulled away to be treated while his wife and the young woman he didn't know were hauled away. The police questioning him hadn't mentioned any rape or sexual assault to him at the house either.

It was a good thing that the police still had an officer there watching over the women. He was able to restrain the irate man while some of the hospital staff were able to subdue him with a shot of something. The ruckus had even drawn in Joanne who was still a floor above where the chaos was happening. She heard the screaming and went down to see what it was. She was about to ask what was going on when Kevin came up behind her and asked her to leave.