Sibling Truth or Dare Club Pt. 03

I woke up the next morning feeling a little rough, I needed coffee, fast!

As I walked into the kitchen, I half expected Jeremy to be there. But there was no sign of him. Good, I didn't think I could handle seeing him right now. So I grabbed my coffee and quickly headed up to my room.

I stayed in my room for most of the day thinking about what had just happened. About how maybe things had gotten a little out of hand. Should we stop doing this? What if someone found out? So many thoughts, so many feelings. I needed a distraction. I decided to go for a run to clear my head.

When I got back from my run, my parents were home from work. I said hi, grabbed a snack, and then quickly retreated back to the safety of my bedroom. Still no sign of Jeremy. I somehow managed to avoid him for the rest of the day.

I woke up Saturday morning to a knock on my door.

"Hey Ange. Your father and I are getting ready to leave. We're going up to the cottage for the night. We'll be back late tomorrow, so you and your brother will have to take care of yourselves for the next two days."

"OK mom, we'll try to stay out of trouble."

She shot me a strange look. But then said goodbye, told me there was money in the kitchen if we needed it, closed my door, and left.

I laid in bed for a while watching a movie but decided it was probably time to venture out into the rest of the house. I needed to talk to Jeremy and try to figure out what was going on.

He was on the couch in the living room watching TV when I went out there. I sat in the armchair across from him.

"Hey Jer. Can we talk?"

"Uh, sure. What's up?"

"I just wanted to talk about the last couple of weeks. About everything that's been going on."

"Oh yeah, it's been pretty wild, eh."

"I know. That's what I wanted to talk about. Is this all too weird? Should we be doing this? Is it time to stop?"

"Hmmm. Ya, I get it. It's certainly been a little weird, but look. Like we said before, we're both adults. We've been talking to two other adults. And it only has to be weird as we make it. It's not like we aren't both aware that the other person is sexually active."

"But we're siblings. Siblings don't normally watch live action sex shows together."

Jeremy laughed. "No, they don't. But look, it's not like we're having sex or anything." His cheeks turned bright red as soon as he said that. "You know what I mean. Sure, it's a little unconventional, but we haven't crossed any lines, and if anything, I think it's made me feel closer to you. We've always been sort of friends, but I've had a lot of fun these past few weeks hanging out with you. I've learned a lot about you too. Some things maybe a brother shouldn't know about his sister, but Truth or Dare is a crazy game where you find out crazy things about the people you're playing with. Let's not overthink it. Let's just try to have fun, and if either of us ever feels uncomfortable, we can stop at any time."

"Ok, sounds like a plan. And I've felt closer to you too. I'm glad we started playing this game. And I'm glad we started playing it together. Ok. Thanks Jer. I feel a lot better about things. I'm going to go grab a shower."

"Ok. Hey! The movie!"

"What?"

"The movie. The dare. We have to watch Part 3 as part of our homework dare."

"Oh ya. I completely forgot about that."

"Do you still want to watch it?"

"Um, yeah, sure. I mean, we were dared to watch it, right? So it'd be breaking the rules if we didn't. But I need a shower first. Back in a second."

* * * * *

I came back downstairs about 30 minutes later refreshed from my shower and wearing some comfortable clothes. As I approached the living room, I could see that Jeremy already had the movie queued up, ready to go on the TV.

"Do you want a drink before we get started?"

"Sure, if you're having one."

I went and mixed us a couple of drinks in the kitchen and returned to the living room. I handed Jeremy his glass and then sat down across from him in the armchair.

"Ok. Ready when you are." I said.

Jeremy hit play on the remote but then quickly paused it again. "Oh shit, I forgot. The second part of the dare."

"Huh?" I said.

"You have to sit here right next to me," he said as he patted the seat next to him on the couch.

"Oh right." I said as I climbed out of my seat and sat next to him on the sofa. I'm not sure why, but I leaned in and briefly put my head on his shoulder. Looking up at him, I said, "Ready?"

He hit play, and the movie began.

The movie begins, but it was clear that this was a much different movie than the other two. There's almost no plot to start the movie as they jump right into their game. And because they've played the game before (it's the same cast), they jump right in to some pretty intense dares.

The first move of the game is a dare. And the brother in the movie is dared to give a blowjob to another guy.

"Holy shit!" I said. "I've never seen two guys together before. But I can't say I'm not intrigued."

And right away the brother walks over, drops to his knees, pulls down the guy's pants, and gives him what looks like an amazing blowjob. It turns out I am very intrigued about the idea of two guys being together. I can feel my skin flushing already. I look over at Jeremy, and his eyes are locked onto the screen. I don't think he minds this scene either.

The next dare is for the sister. She's dared to fist herself in front of the group.

"Looks familiar," I said to Jeremy.

He just nodded, clearly focused on the action before us. It was definitely hot, but I couldn't help but think Caleigh looked better.

I thought things were going to calm down a little bit when the next turn was a truth. Someone asked the brother's girlfriend what her craziest fantasy was. She said she wanted to watch her boyfriend and his sister make out and feel each other up.

"Wow!" Both Jeremy and I said it in unison, followed by some nervous laughter.

The next two turns were dares; one of the other girls had to finger herself to orgasm and then lick her fingers clean. And one of the couples had to 69 with each other for 5 minutes.

At this point in the movie, they decided to take a little break from the game and get some drinks. We decided this would be a good time to pause the movie and refill our cups as well as grab some popcorn.

As the movie resumed and everyone was returning back to their seats, the brother was the last person to enter the room, and the only available seat was next to his sister. But seeing as this was a 3-person couch, and was about to make room for 4 people, it was a little bit of a tight squeeze, and their legs and arms were touching when he sat down.

It was the sister's turn to take a dare now. And she was dared to masturbate, with her clothes on, until she had an orgasm. She awkwardly glanced at her brother but quickly decided to complete the dare. She slumped back into the couch, unbuttoned her jeans, and slid her hand inside. The whole room really started to get into this dare, cheering her on. Everyone except her brother, who was sitting as still as he could next to her, wide-eyed, eyes focused on the movement of her hand. Occasionally glancing up at her face.

She was completely caught up in the dare, using her other hand to massage her ample breasts over her shirt. And after a few minutes, her body tensed, and she let the orgasm wash through her body, closing her eyes and slumping even further into the couch.

Everyone cheered and told her how hot that was. Even her brother managed to show a little appreciation for the show she had just put on for everyone.

It was one of the other women's turns, and she dared everyone in the room to strip naked.

"Might as well get our clothes out of the way from now on." She said.

And so everyone stood up and took their clothes off. A few of them taking a little extra time to put on a bit of a show. But now they were all completely nude and took their places back in their seats. As soon as they sat down, the brother and sister realized their bare skin was now touching. Both of them were feeling a little uncomfortable but tried not to let it show.

It was the brothers turn again to accept a challenge, and he chose dare. The dare was to do the same thing his sister did, but this time there were no clothes to hide what was happening.

He was already rock hard from all the action that was taking place, and so he started right away. Unsure exactly where to look, he kept his eyes focused mostly on his girlfriend but would occasionally glance around the room.

"Oh god. I'm going to cum!" He declared with a sense of urgency in his voice. "Where should I finish?"

His girlfriend quickly sprung into action and jumped across the room, landing at his feet. She cupped her hands and extended them towards her boyfriend. "Here. Cum for me, baby. Cum in my hands. This is so hot. Show everyone how that huge cock of yours is so full of cum."

That was enough to set him over the edge. He threw his head back and let his orgasm take control. But the comfort of having his girlfriend in between his legs might have made him relax a little too much because as his cock began spurting, he missed his girlfriend's hands with the first spurt, and it shot up and landed right on his sister's outer thigh. A look of pure shock spread across her face.

"Oops!" His girlfriend exclaimed, quickly grabbing his cock and pointing it at her own chest just in time to catch subsequent blasts.

The brother hadn't noticed what had happened, as he was so caught up in his own pleasure. But he looked down just in time to see his girlfriend reaching over to his sister's leg, wiping the cum from her thigh, licking it clean from her fingers, and then casually stating, "Oops, sorry about that. Aim was a little off.".

She sprung to her feet as if nothing had happened and headed back to her seat. Once seated, she proceeded to scrape the cum off of her tits and stomach, making sure not a single drop went to waste. You could tell this wasn't the first time she had swallowed her boyfriend's cum.

Everybody took a big swig of their drinks, and the game continued.

I had been so enthralled by the action screen. I totally forgot I was watching the movie with someone else. Let alone my own brother. I glanced over at him, and he seemed equally focused on the action on the screen. I'm not sure why, but I took a quick glance at his crotch and saw that he was enjoying the movie as much as I was.

Back in the movie, things didn't exactly calm down from there. The single woman and a woman from one of the couples were dared to 69 with each other for 10 minutes or until one of them came. They didn't make the full 10 minutes. One of the couples was dared to have anal sex, which I thought was pretty wild. One of the women dared to let her husband's throat fuck her. Her mascara was running down her face afterwards; she was an absolute mess. But I don't think she cared one bit.

And then the brothers girlfriend dared the sister to make out with her for 5 minutes.

The sister admitted that she had never made out with another woman before. But she was willing to, if the girlfriend took it easy on her.

"Not a chance!" The girlfriend replied with a grin.

The girlfriend came over and straddled the sister right on the couch and immediately started making out with her. After a few seconds, they stopped, and the sister had a bit of a concerned look on her face. They started making out again, and it took me a second to realize what was going on. The sister could taste something different when kissing the girlfriend. She could taste her brother. A lightning bolt shot through my pussy as that realization really struck home with me. Holy shit she was tasting her own brothers cum. This movie was wild!

I'm almost positive that's what the sister was thinking when she paused at the beginning of the dare. But she certainly didn't let it stop her because they really went at each other for the rest of the time. Someone had to call TIME three times before they pulled away from each other.

"Hey Jer. Can we pause it for a minute? I gotta pee." I lied, but I did need a quick break. And the washroom would be the perfect spot for it.

Jeremy paused the movie as I took off up the stairs to the bathroom. I was barely inside when I jammed my hand into my soaked underwear and brought myself to one of the quickest orgasms of my life. Holy shit. I needed that. I took a few minutes to let myself calm down. I washed my hands and headed back into the living room.

"Did you have a good tinkle?" Jeremy asked with a stupid grin on this face.

I punched him in the arm as I sat back down beside him. "Shut up and hit play."

The game continued, but to be honest, it turned into more of a porn movie than a believable game of truth or dare. One of the guys got pegged with a strap-on by one of the girls. One of the girls was tied up, and everyone was allowed to do whatever they wanted to her for one minute. The sister was dared to let one of the other guys cum on her face. The girlfriend got double-penetrated by the two guys that weren't her boyfriend. It got pretty wild at the end, and probably a little outside of the realms of a game of truth or dare. But I wasn't complaining. It was all pretty hot.

That scene ended, and I thought the movie was over. But a new scene began. It was days later, and the brother and sister were watching a movie when the doorbell rang. It was the girlfriend. She came bounding into the room and gave them each a more than friendly kiss.

"That was quite the game the other night, eh? Can you believe that Jess fucked Steve with that strap-on? That was wild!"

The girlfriend asked the siblings if they wanted to have a private game just the three of them. Of course they all agreed.

The sister went first and picked truth. The girlfriend didn't hesitate and came strong right out of the gate.

"What did you think about being able to taste your brothers cum when we made out during the last game?"

"What?!?" Jeremy exclaimed while also pausing the movie. "Wait, what's she talking about?"

"You didn't catch that part? When they were dared to make out during the game, as soon as they started kissing, they paused for a second and pulled out of the kiss. The sister had a strange look on her face, but before she could say anything, the girlfriend started kissing her again. I was 99% sure that's what happened, but this confirms it."

"Holy shit, that's wild. She kissed her brother's girlfriend right after she cleaned his cum off her own chest and ate it all. And then they made out! I thought it was crazy enough when he came on her leg. I gotta see what happens next."

Jeremy didn't seem to be bothered by any of this. I was curious to see where this scene was heading. He hit play on the remote.

"Um..what?" It was clear that the brother in the movie was as clueless as Jeremy had been.

"I was kind of weirded out at first. But you're so hot, and I've always wanted to make out with you that I just tried to focus on that."

"I thought it was pretty hot!" The girlfriend stated.

The sister wanted to change the subject, so she said, "Brother dear, truth or dare?"

"Truth, I guess."

"What was your favourite part of the game?"

"Um, I'm not sure if I should say."

"Come on, don't be a wimp," the girlfriend retorted.

"Ok. Fine. It was when my sister had an orgasm while fully clothed. I don't know why, but it was just so sensual, and the fact that you had your clothes on made it so hot."

"Holy fuck yes!" The girlfriend enthusiastically added.

I wasn't sure if she was agreeing with her boyfriend or excited by his response.

"Ok, truth or dare?" The brother asked his girlfriend.

"Truth."

"If you could have one thing happen right now, and I mean anything, what would it be?"

"I'd want to help the two of you have sex. It would be all you two, but I'd be there to support you, cheer you on, hold your hair back, whatever. But I'd do anything to watch the two of you make love."

"No way, they aren't really going to do that, are they?" Jeremy asked, pausing the movie yet again.

"Looks like it," I responded.

"Do you want to keep watching or stop here?" He replied.

"We have to complete the dare."

"Oh ya. Right. Fuck. Ok. This is one crazy ass movie." Jeremy said, clearly rattled, but he picked up the remote and hit play.

"You know what?" The girlfriend asked rhetorically. "Fuck this truth or dare shit. Can I watch the two of you have sex?"

The siblings looked at each other, then back at the girlfriend, then at the same time they both said, "Yes!"

And that was it. The siblings embraced into one of the hottest kissing scenes I've ever seen. I couldn't believe what I was watching. I mean, they were just actors, but was I about to see an incest scene in a movie? A movie I was watching with my brother?

The girlfriend came up behind her boyfriend and helped him lift his shirt off. The sister decided to removed her shirt too, while their kiss had been momentarily interrupted. They started making out again, and the girlfriend went to work freeing the sisters tits from her bra.

Next, she started helping each of them remove their pants and, lastly, their underwear and socks. She took a step back to admire her work. The siblings were standing there completely naked, making out.

They stopped briefly, and the sister said, "Can we take this to the bedroom?"

And the scene transitioned to the sister climbing onto the bed with her brother close behind.

"I can't believe this is happening!" Proclaimed the girlfriend. "This is the hottest thing I've ever seen!"

The sister lied on her back, and her brother came up and started kissing her. Then he began working his way down her neck, finally coming to her tits.

"I've always dreamed of playing with these," he stated.

He spent quite a bit of time working back and forth between her breasts, focusing a lot of attention on her nipples. And it was work that didn't go unnoticed by his sister.

He then began to kiss his way down her stomach and buried his face between her legs.

"OMG, I can't believe my brother is eating my pussy!"

"I can't believe the two of you are letting me be a part of this."

And he spent the next few minutes bringing his sister to orgasm. Before crawling back up and kissing her with a face full of her own juices.

"Are you ready for this?" He asked his sister.

"Are you?" She replied.

"I think so. This is so crazy!"

With one hand, his sister grabbed him by the back of the neck and pulled him in for another deep kiss. Then she reached between them and grabbed his cock and guided it towards her opening. She had a hard time positioning things properly because of how they were laying, but the girlfriend quickly helped guide his cock to the right spot.

Then while looking his sister directly in the eyes, he began to slowly push inside her.

"Oh my fucking god!!!" The girlfriend screamed. "This is the sexiest thing I've ever seen. I can't believe I'm watching this in person; this is incest, real live incest, and it's amazing!! How does it feel?"

The sister went to respond, but just as she was about to speak, her brother thrust back into her, and she closed her eyes, threw her head back, and had a huge orgasm.

Her brother kept fucking her over and over; I was jealous. Wait fuck. Did I really just think that? I meant about the fucking. Fuck.

I quickly glanced over at Jeremy to see how he was reacting. His eyes were wider than I've ever seen them, and I glanced down at his crotch, and he was gripping his erection on the outside of his shorts. I looked down and noticed that my hand was firmly planted between my legs as well.

Back on screen, the brother's pace had quickened, and he screamed out, "I'm going to cum soon."