Note: You can change font size, font face, and turn on dark mode by clicking the "A" icon tab in the Story Info Box.
You can temporarily switch back to a Classic Literotica® experience during our ongoing public Beta testing. Please consider leaving feedback on issues you experience or suggest improvements.
Click herePhoenix reluctantly pulled back and dipped her face again for another quick kiss. She pulled back to look into James' eyes, and he watched her with equal need.
She turned to her sister. "We were grinding our pelvis' together as we kissed."
Phoebe grinned and locked eyes with James. He nodded to her, so she immediately pressed her body against his. Phoenix moved her hands from James' back down to his ass.
James sucked on her tongue as he rubbed his groin against hers. He gripped her ass in his palms and squeezed. A tremor went through her body, and she leaned back to moan loudly.
When she opened her eyes, she looked at her sister in awe. "Oh my god, this feels so good!"
Phoenix grinned. "I think James agrees."
Phoebe reluctantly pulled back as the three of them fidgeted.
"I'd like to continue exploring this, but we're overdressed," Phoenix suggested.
James' brain was coming back to him, and he realized they were suggesting they get naked. That would mean they'd see the ring.
"Uh, there's something you need to know before that happens," he said.
"You're a virgin?" Phoebe asked.
"No—I mean yes... I am, but that wasn't what I was going to say," he continued. He took a deep breath. "Sometime during the attack on me, someone glued a ring on my... penis."
The sisters looked at each other, and then Phoenix grinned at him. "You're wearing a cock ring? Kinky man!"
He exhaled in annoyance. "I just said someone else put it on. I can't get it off!"
Phoebe frowned. "How are you getting erections if there is a ring on it? Doesn't that hurt?"
James' expression became unsure, and he shook his head. "I don't know how it does it, but the ring seems to grow too."
Now, the ladies were staring at him with shocked expressions. "Can we see it?" Phoebe asked softly.
He took a deep breath, then undid his pants and slid them down his legs. He stopped as he looked at the twins. "Am I the only one undressing?"
They burst into giggles and scrambled to catch up to him.
He pulled his pants off with his socks and tugged his shirt over his head.
He was down to his boxers when he saw they were only wearing their panties.
James stopped as he admired their bodies then he realized he was gawking. "Sorry. Your bodies... are so beautiful!"
They smiled happily and pointed to his underwear. He was already showing against the fabric.
He nodded nervously and pulled them down, and the twins froze.
James saw they were staring at the ring, so he also looked down. He was very stiff and tingling madly from their previous activities, but the ring wasn't pinching or blocking circulation. He couldn't even feel it. If he wasn't staring at it, he wouldn't be able to tell he was wearing it.
"So... that's it," he said.
"May... may we touch it?" Phoebe managed to say quietly.
"Uh, sure," he responded, and they immediately reached out to run a finger along the ring's surface over the writing.
He sucked in a sharp breath as he felt their touch, and it was good.
They pulled their hands back quickly and looked at him, but he shook his head.
"I can't feel the ring, but when you touch it, I feel your fingers on my skin. It's the weirdest thing!" he said quietly.
"It's beautiful!" Phoenix said quietly as her eyes returned to the ring. She reached out and took his cock in her hand. "It's so hot!"
James was a little confused, unsure if she was still discussing his jewelry.
Then, all he could think about was how nice it was to feel her hand on him.
Phoebe smiled at her sister. "This is the first one we've seen in person. It's giving me naughty thoughts."
Phoenix giggled as she pulled her hand back and made her sister wrap her fingers around James' cock.
"Ooohoohoo!" Phoebe gasped as she gently squeezed. Her eyes widened excitedly as she looked at her sister. "I want to ride this! I want it inside me!"
When she saw his eyes open suddenly at her sister's words, Phoenix glanced at James. "Would that be okay with you, James? We brought protection," Phoenix asked before he could object.
James struggled to think as Phoebe massaged him so well with her hand. "S-sex? Phoebe wants to have sex? With me?"
Phoebe felt a thrill rush through her body hearing the words. She nodded to him, and he held her eyes as he nodded in return.
"I'd be honored," James said, and Phoebe giggled at his old-fashioned formality.
Phoenix got them moving when she gently pulled her sister's hand from James and guided him down to lie on the carpet. She reached into the gym bag and pulled out a box of thirty-six large-size condoms. Having appreciated his package a few days earlier, they knew this was the most appropriate size for him. Looking at his raging hardon, they knew they'd chosen correctly. She also grabbed a tube of lube and a packet of wet wipes.
While they may have been virgins for actual sex with a partner, both sisters had toys for relieving that particular itch. James was larger than the toys, so lube was a necessity.
Phoebe knelt on the carpet next to James and kissed him again. He seemed to enjoy that, and when his hands came up to hold her, they landed on her breasts. She gasped once more and held his hands against her.
Phoenix rolled one of the condoms over his erection and squirted a little lube on her palm before she gripped him and rubbed the slippery stuff up and down his shaft.
James jolted and moaned into Phoebe's kiss.
"Now, sis," Phoenix said, and Phoebe pulled back from the kiss and swung a leg over his body. She eased back as her sister pointed him toward her descending pussy.
Contact!
Everyone gasped then Phoebe began pushing down in surges as he opened her wider than she'd ever been before. He wasn't enormously endowed but was still larger than she'd taken.
The woman began to make small grunting noises with each push, and her eyes were wide but dazed.
"Does it hurt?" Phoenix asked quietly.
"No... it's so good! He's filling me up so well!" Phoebe moaned in bliss.
James reached his left hand down between them and began to massage Phoebe's clit in gentle circles.
"OH, FUCK!" she exclaimed as she slammed herself down to take the last two inches. "Fuck!Fuck!Fuck!"
Her hips began to roll and twitch as James kept his hand in play.
Phoenix watched this in awe and moved down to see James entering her sister, who was beginning to bounce up and down faster and faster.
Then she noticed the glow.
The letters on the ring were beginning to shine with a gold light. The condom was covering the ring, but moments later, the latex over the ring split and rolled away from the metal. Before she could warn her, Phoebe slammed down again, and the ring pressed tight against her skin. She threw her head back with her mouth wide open as she screamed silently. Phoebe froze as she watched her expression, afraid she was experiencing agony from being burned by the ring.
She saw Phoebe trembling, then shaking as she slowly leaned forward and kissed James tenderly.
They were both breathing hard and smiled at each other.
"What... are you okay?" Phoenix asked her sister as she noted the ring was no longer glowing.
Phoebe turned her head languidly. "That was... the best... I've ever felt!"
Phoenix almost mentioned the glowing letters on the ring, but something told her it was too soon for James to know.
As she eased herself off James' cock, Phoebe continued to tremble and shake. "Fuck, I'm so sensitive!" she gasped.
When she managed to move aside, Phoenix stared at James' still-hard cock. He hadn't come. She quickly rolled off the ruined condom and the base ring, which had separated from the condom. She rolled on a fresh one and lubed it well as James watched her hungrily. She was becoming tingly just from his gaze. She eased her leg over him and guided the head to her opening. She gasped quietly as she felt the head pop inside then her thoughts were pushed aside as sensation became all. He was thick and hot and sliding so deep into her body.
James was in heaven. Phoebe had been so hot and tight around his cock, but Phoenix felt like she was clamping down on him with every inch she managed to take. He could feel his release getting closer.
He reached down with his left hand again and began to gently strum her clit. She responded more dramatically than her sister, so he reduced the pressure he used.
He wasn't sure how he knew how to do this, but they seemed to like it.
Phoenix slammed James deep and began to bounce on his cock again and again. At the bottom of each stroke, she felt a deep, warm tingle growing in her pussy. Then, she was driving him into her body frantically as the pleasure began to race out of control.
When she slammed down for the last time, it felt like her entire body had become incandescent, glowing fiercely as wave after wave of bliss exploded through her. She felt his heat firing into her body, but it was muted, so it must have been caught in the condom.
She leaned forward as her sister had and kissed James. More sparks jumped through her body. She needed Phoebe's help to dismount as her legs shook too much.
When she was free, she checked and saw the condom was still on and had captured his cum. She sighed in relief.
Phoebe did the task of collecting the condom and looked at her sister in concern when she noticed the base had somehow torn free from the rest. Phoenix just shook her head slightly for her to let it go. Phoebe tied off the used rubber and dropped it into the trash bag with their dinner waste. She grabbed the wipes and handed them out so they could freshen themselves up. These went into the bag as well.
Phoenix stretched out next to James, and Phoebe did the same on his other side.
They grinned at him happily as he smiled back.
"That was really amazing!" James sighed. "I can see why everyone seems so obsessed with sex."
The twins burst into giggles.
He rolled his head from side to side to enjoy their happiness. Then he got a little tongue-tied. "I don't mean to sound stupid, but I'm just going to say it because I don't know any better." He sighed. "Does this mean we're boyfriend and girlfriends?"
They smiled, and the sisters looked at each other over James.
Phoebe spoke for them as she usually did. "Can we start as friends with benefits? We're just getting to know each other. We don't know what this might become. We both like you a lot. You're also really sexy, and we enjoyed our time with you tonight. We learned a lot and have a lot to think about. Is that okay?"
James looked into their eyes and realized he was far better off now than earlier in the day. He had friends!
"Yes, that sounds great to me. I really like you, too."
"Give us your cell number so we can send you messages," Phoenix suggested.
He gave them an awkward look. "I don't have a cell phone."
They looked at him in surprise. "Everyone has a cell phone!" Phoebe said.
He shrugged. "I'm here on a free-ride scholarship and use the meal plan for a reason. I can't afford a phone or a plan, but you can reach me by my college email address. I check it here on the loaner laptop the campus supplied."
"Sorry! I didn't mean to be rude," Phoebe said contritely.
He waved a hand. "It's fine. You don't miss what you've never had," he said with a smile as he quoted his grandpa. "I'd like to pay my share for dinner. I insist," he said.
The ladies grinned at him. "No," they said in unison, and James couldn't help but smile and surrender.
They collected their clothes and pulled them back on. Phoenix put the box of condoms, the lube, and the wipes into the drawer of his nightstand with a grin.
Then they were ready to go.
"We had an amazing time tonight," Phoebe said, and her sister nodded enthusiastically.
James grinned widely. "I did, too. I have a question, though."
They looked at him curiously.
He gestured to the bed. "Any particular reason we didn't use the bed?"
The ladies chuckled. "You have a lovely soft rug, and we'd make far too much noise on that bed. They're not very strong. At least, compared to us," Phoenix explained.
"Ah! Thanks for the enlightenment," he said, walking them to the door. They paused to kiss him as they stepped outside, and he enjoyed that. He waved to them as they walked down the corridor. When he turned to go back inside, he spotted two male students staring at him in shock. He nodded and stepped back inside to close and lock his door.
He had homework to do.
-=-
When Phoebe and Phoenix returned to their room, they locked up and dropped back onto their beds. They looked over at each other and grinned.
"Okay, what did we learn tonight?" Phoebe asked.
"Sex is good!" her sister sighed.
"Yes, yes. Agreed, but you know what I meant."
Phoenix looked inside to see if she felt the burning need to be near James. "I don't feel the compulsion anymore, but I don't know if it's gone permanently."
Phoebe nodded. "Yes, I agree. Waiting for him on the steps today, I could feel the urge, but now it's quiet."
"Something else we learned is that he's the opposite of Richard Madden. He's a good person, an innocent," Phoenix said.
"But no longer a virgin," her sister said with a grin.
Phoenix beaned her sister in the head with a thrown plushie. "The same can be said about us."
"The ring's magic is working. It resizes to match the size of his cock. That's impossible for a solid metal ring," Phoebe said.
"It doesn't like to be covered by a condom. The letters glow and burn through the latex," Phoenix said, and her sister jolted up to a sitting position to stare at her.
"WHAT?" she gasped.
"I saw it when you were riding James, but I had no time to warn you. Maybe the ring needs to touch his partners. I got to experience it, too. It feels incredible!" Phoenix explained.
"Are we going to share this with the others?" Phoebe asked her sister nervously.
Phoenix was quiet as she tried to think of a way to warn the others without sounding like a slut. Then she looked at her sister and spoke her fears out loud. "Are we sluts?"
Phoebe must have been thinking along the same lines as she jolted slightly to hear the thought outside her head. "I-I don't feel like one. I mean, yes, we had sex with a man we'd only spoken to twice, but I don't feel like fucking any man that asks."
"Not that many men do," Phoenix said, and her sister saw she was agreeing with her and nodded.
"There was the magic compulsion to be near him," Phoenix offered.
"But not to fuck him. It never felt like that," Phoebe asserted.
"True. I was attracted to James physically when we first met him in the woods and after talking with him, I genuinely like him," Phoenix said with a smile.
"So, how do we explain the condoms to the others?" Phoebe asked.
"How they burn off the ends?" Phoenix replied.
"No! How do we explain why we bought and brought them in the first place!" the sister stressed.
"Ah, right," Phoenix sighed and thought about that briefly. "Honestly, it was just wishful thinking for me. I know he's no Ryan Gosling or Henry Cavill, but he's... classically handsome? There's also something about his eyes. There's an honesty there. No cruelty, sarcasm, or condescension. I felt safe and free to speak my mind without feeling like I was being judged."
Phoebe was smiling dreamily. "I like how he looked at us. It made me feel beautiful and desired."
"Yes!" her sister gasped and giddily drummed her heels on her mattress as she hugged herself with a grin.
They were quiet for a bit as they recalled their evening.
"Are you feeling the compulsion returning?" Phoebe asked quietly.
Phoenix examined her feelings and shook her head. "No, I don't feel the magic behind it."
"But you do want to see him again," the sister clarified.
Phoenix shared a smile with her sister. "We both do, but we must see if the compulsion returns."
"Shit," Phoebe moaned.
They'd have to deny themselves a repeat performance to ensure they were truly free.
But at least they had something to tell the others.
Chapter 10
The following evening, the coven met for a special meeting at Katherine's home. The ladies found seats in the cozy sitting room and admired the décor, but they were mostly concerned with the state of their High Priestess. They quickly picked up that Katherine wasn't in the best of spirits. They saw her eyes were glassy and she looked like she hadn't been getting much sleep. They were worried for her.
Jennifer settled them and gave the floor to Katherine, who stood to address her coven. She took them through their daily observances and asked for the Goddess' Blessings. Then she looked into their eyes.
"Thank you all so much for making time to join us tonight. I know you have busy schedules, so I will try not to take too much of your time." She took a deep breath. "As you are aware, through some strange twist of fate, our target for the ceremony was switched, and Richard had a far more violent conclusion for his evening."
There was a low murmur as the ladies recalled the stories of how Richard ended up in the hospital.
Katherine lifted her hand, and they quieted again.
"Instead of that wicked man, we performed the ceremony on an innocent one," her voice broke a little, but she rallied.
"I haven't been completely honest with you, or myself for that matter. When the ring came into my possession, and I felt the strength of its magic, I found a way to get vengeance against Charles Madden and his corrupt corporation. Yes, there would be a beneficial outcome if we directed the company to produce medicines for the world for fair prices and prevented them from withholding necessary medication from those in need. But my need for punishing them led me to break the most sacred vow of Wicca. Do no harm," Katherine said in shame.
The twins were confused as they'd experienced the ring's influence directly and sensed no harm in them or James. "We don't understand! James hasn't been harmed!" Phoebe exclaimed.
Katherine shook her head. "A critical element I kept from you was that the ring's magic wasn't a spell. It was a curse. Applied to Richard, it would have made him our slave and stripped him of his free will. Applied to the wicked, the ring controls the wearer. But worn by the innocent, the curse reverses, and the wearer controls those who bound him to it."
Now, the ladies were much more vocal about their upset. They didn't want to be slaves!
Jennifer stood and managed to quiet the outraged women. She caught Phoebe trying to get her attention and addressed the group. "Please remain calm. I believe Phoebe and Phoenix have met with James Bailey and can shed some light on their experience." She turned to them. "Ladies?"
The twins stood to face the others and saw their upset expressions. Some looked like they were moments away from bursting into tears. Phoebe took a deep breath.
"We went to speak with James the day he was released from the hospital. He was bruised and in pain. We immediately felt compelled to protect him. It was definitely the magic at work. We offered to be his bodyguards, but he gracefully declined, and that compulsion eased." She glanced at Jennifer as what she would say next went against the woman's wishes. "The next day we met him after classes and invited him to share dinner in his room, a floor picnic." She caught Jennifer's frown but continued. "We needed more information on how the magic worked. James is completely oblivious of the ring's effect. He truly is an innocent. He's also a really nice man as well as being handsome—"
"You had sex with him!" Rose gasped as she stared at them and caught Phoenix's expression. "Both of you?"
Now, all the women were shouting or crying, and Jennifer once more struggled to get control.
"SHUT UP! WE'RE NOT FINISHED!" Phoenix yelled loudly, cutting through the chaos. The two large women glared at the others until they sat and sullenly listened.